anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (Default)
Anghraine ([personal profile] anghraine) wrote2010-07-27 05:58 am

Personal canon: P&P

We all have a personal canon -- the X that exists in our heads, with all the little additions and details our minds supply.  Sort of like fanon, but for one person instead of a weird fandom virus.  So, for Pride and Prejudice, this is mine:

(1) Lady Catherine adored Lady Anne and loves her children.

(2) Mrs Bennet’s name is Jane.  Her family always called her Jenny, but Mr Bennet never has.  (His given name is James.  She’s never called him that, either.)

(3) Darcy has never seriously pursued a woman in his life.  If he had, he’d have some idea how to go about it.  (Eavesdropping totally doesn’t count.)

(4) Bingley has fallen genuinely in love before.  That doesn’t make his love for Jane any less sincere than if she were his first attachment. 

(5) Elizabeth loves dogs.  Darcy prefers cats.

(6) Mary was never in love with Mr Collins, though she did approve of him, and would have gladly married him.

(7) Kitty isn’t clever or staggeringly beautiful or good-natured or, really, anything much at all.  But she can be trusted to keep a secret.

(8) Until Georgiana, Darcy was the youngest of the Fitzwilliam grandchildren.  Even Anne is two months older than he is.

(9) In Darcy’s family, nicknames are rare and strictly regulated; he never had one himself, and he never dreams of calling his wife and sister anything more informal than Elizabeth and Georgiana.  (Nor does it ever occur to him that Elizabeth, relentlessly Lizzy’d and Eliza’d for twenty-one years, would feel anything about this – let alone relief.)

(10) Jane does believe what she says.  This does not make her stupid.  It doesn’t even necessarily make her wrong.

(11) Lydia never changes, except to become rather more ambitious.  When her children grow to adulthood, she relives her youth through them.

(12) Darcy is a thwarted idealist.  Elizabeth is not.

(13) Mr Gardiner always assures his sister that, even if worse did come to worse, he would take care of her and her daughters. She never listens.

(14) Mrs Gardiner is the natural daughter of somebody.

(15) Darcy’s parents did not marry for love.  Elizabeth’s did, for a certain value of “love.”

(16) Caroline was never in love with Darcy.  At all.  She isn’t a spawn of hell, either, though she’s always a rather unpleasant person.  (Louisa is not appreciably better.)

(17) Darcy's probably homozygous everything.  He's very inbred.

(18) To Elizabeth, Pemberley matters not as a display of wealth or importance, but of elegance.  She always knew Darcy was rich.  She never imagined he had taste.

(19) Fitzwilliam and Darcy have been best friends for as long as they can remember. As boys, they were all but inseparable; as men, they are . . . all but inseparable.  They’re cousins and companions and one another’s only serious confidants.  Even Georgiana thinks of Fitzwilliam as a sort of youngish uncle: her almost-father’s almost-brother.

(20) Charlotte is an aromantic asexual.

(21) Anne de Bourgh is selfish and spoilt, but she's genuinely ill.

(22) Even when they share a bed, Darcy and Elizabeth do not share a bedroom.

(She steals the blankets.  He rearranges her writing desk.  She leaves her robe on the floor.  He hangs incomphrensible paintings on his wall.  She ... yeah.)

This is probably for the best.  It'd be a tragedy if they murdered one another.

(23) Jane, Elizabeth and Lydia marry in the mid-1790s, their hair down and their skirts full(ish).

(24) Darcy's relatives are numerous, ambitious, ridiculously interrelated, and affectionate.  He's been solving their problems, settling their disputes, and generally arranging their lives for years, to the satisfaction of all.  (Upon their marriage, Elizabeth stumbles into a position of unprecedented authority, at first because she controls access to Darcy and later because she somehow morphed into a matriarch when she wasn't looking. It's all vastly amusing.)

(25) Darcy and Elizabeth, Jane and Bingley, Colonel Fitzwilliam and Mary Crawford, the colonel's brother and Georgiana, even Mr Bennet, Lady Catherine, Anne, Kitty and her clergyman -- in their (very) different ways, they all live happily ever after.
sixbeforelunch: a striking woman wearing an ornate hat and necklace (Default)

[personal profile] sixbeforelunch 2010-07-28 12:18 am (UTC)(link)
(4) Bingley has fallen genuinely in love before. That doesn’t make his love for Jane any less sincere than if she were his first attachment.

Yes! And, um, honestly, if he had never gotten back to Jane for whatever reason, chances are he'd go on to be happy with someone else. (Bingley/Georgiana would probably work out pretty well, I think.)

Massive agreement also on 10, 19, 21 and 22.
sixbeforelunch: a striking woman wearing an ornate hat and necklace (Default)

i wish i could edit my comments

[personal profile] sixbeforelunch 2010-07-28 12:27 am (UTC)(link)
Re: #4, have I ever mentioned my desire to write Bingley/Lady Susan Vernon when Bingley was, like, 17? Not that Bingley was in love with her exactly, but...well, that was a fun couple of months.
sixbeforelunch: a striking woman wearing an ornate hat and necklace (Default)

[personal profile] sixbeforelunch 2010-07-28 02:01 am (UTC)(link)
My Bingley/Georgiana plot bunny is stalled largely because it's so disturbing. It's Georgiana's affair in Ramsgate getting abroad and Darcy needing to get her married off and, well, Bingley is there. But ZOMG it's so depressing from there. Even the mostly happy ending I have cooked up doesn't make up for the myriad of awfulness that the characters would have to go through to get there because Georigana is scarred and teetering on the edge of a breakdown and Darcy still trying to act like Georgiana's parent/brother even though she's supposed to be Bingley's wife and Bingley is trying to deal with his wife's post-trauma and his feelings for Jane and Georgiana is driving Bingley up a wall because her adolescent sexuality is uncertain and an unintentional tease to his adult sexuality (she wants to play at being sexual but have the safety of retreating when things start to get heavy, he just wants to bed her). Not good. I doubt I'll actually ever write it because I don't want to go that dark and also because I can't envision the story without dealing explicitly with the sexual nature of the relationship which is not something I'm comfortable doing.

But fluffy-cute Bingley/Georgiana might be fun. It would probably consist of Georgiana being a bit older and Darcy and Caroline and Louisa and even a somewhat reluctant Col F trying to play matchmaker and Bingley and Georgiana being completely oblivious to the whole thing to the frustration of all their relations.
sixbeforelunch: a striking woman wearing an ornate hat and necklace (Default)

Re: ghhhh

[personal profile] sixbeforelunch 2010-07-30 01:43 am (UTC)(link)
Oh, it's horrible. I had the basic idea of Bingley/Georgiana FMS and then rolled it around in my head for a while and realized that in order to do it properly, I'd have to go so dark and disturbing that I'd never be able to make it through. The "happy ending" is when Bingley finally leaves Georgiana and goes abroad for five years and when he comes back she's had time to heal and grow up and they can finally try to make things work, but even that is very bitter sweet.

Fluffy cute Bingley/Georgiana would make me happy. People would keep leaving them alone together and praising one of them to the other and Bingley and Georgiana would take forever to figure it out. I am deeply amused by the thought of Bingley asking Darcy and Fitzwilliam for permission to marry her.