Truly, the multitudes celebrity
Jul. 1st, 2026 06:53 pmSo, I made a light-hearted addition to my old TOS Kirk vs AOS Kirk theory over on Tumblr, involving a bunch of screencaps—I just used old ones I already had for TOS, but I had to search for AOS Kirk ones since the films made basically no impression on me except in retrospect when I started marathoning TOS, and I only had a couple images saved (one for an ancient Star Wars photoset in which I used Saldaña's Uhura as my f!Lando dreamcast).
And in the course of dredging up the right length of screenshots for my silly Pride post, I encountered some exceptionally dreary takes on the greatness of AOS Kirk totally capturing the classic character (/eyeroll), but also occasionally "we had a question about the films and felt the need to ask William Shatner about it, person notably Not Appearing in These Films." In the course of these, I just ended up laughing because... I mean, what did they expect? Literally the first time I read an interview with him, I had to drastically re-evaluate almost every detail I'd fandom osmosed except "chaos gremlin, for love of the game."
Anyway, the main three Shatner AOS opinions I encountered in my search for screenshots, because as far as I could tell people literally just kept asking:
1) One reporter breathlessly asked him if he didn't think AOS perfectly captured his Kirk back in TOS. He trollishly pretended to contemplate this for a few seconds, then very deliberately enunciated: "Bullshit."
(Genuinely kind of cathartic as a TOS Kirk stan who absolutely despises the constant attempts to cannibalize TOS as a whole for the benefit of the franchise and insist each ensuing set of retcons and dubious-interpretations-asserted-as-obvious-facts aren't fundamentally distinct from the original. Pine does great work with a drastically different character beyond anything about the premise.)
2) Also, he was asked what actor he'd choose to play him if there was going to be a biopic or something (I can only imagine what a Shatner biopic would even look like, honestly—the man has lived a lot of life and the tone would have to be incredibly grim without his own layer of zany over it all or exclude a lot). Anyway, he said "Chris Pine" and presumably didn't break into maniacal cackling by sheer force of will.
3) Another time, he was asked how he thinks Chris Pine should handle the pay dispute preventing the fourth AOS film. His opinion was that Pine shouldn't bend an inch, because he's talented and attractive and so identified with his role that they can't really make those movies without him, but Pine can do plenty of things other than Star Trek. So if Paramount's going to make that much money, Pine should absolutely see his fair share and if not, walk, and good for him.
And in the course of dredging up the right length of screenshots for my silly Pride post, I encountered some exceptionally dreary takes on the greatness of AOS Kirk totally capturing the classic character (/eyeroll), but also occasionally "we had a question about the films and felt the need to ask William Shatner about it, person notably Not Appearing in These Films." In the course of these, I just ended up laughing because... I mean, what did they expect? Literally the first time I read an interview with him, I had to drastically re-evaluate almost every detail I'd fandom osmosed except "chaos gremlin, for love of the game."
Anyway, the main three Shatner AOS opinions I encountered in my search for screenshots, because as far as I could tell people literally just kept asking:
1) One reporter breathlessly asked him if he didn't think AOS perfectly captured his Kirk back in TOS. He trollishly pretended to contemplate this for a few seconds, then very deliberately enunciated: "Bullshit."
(Genuinely kind of cathartic as a TOS Kirk stan who absolutely despises the constant attempts to cannibalize TOS as a whole for the benefit of the franchise and insist each ensuing set of retcons and dubious-interpretations-asserted-as-obvious-facts aren't fundamentally distinct from the original. Pine does great work with a drastically different character beyond anything about the premise.)
2) Also, he was asked what actor he'd choose to play him if there was going to be a biopic or something (I can only imagine what a Shatner biopic would even look like, honestly—the man has lived a lot of life and the tone would have to be incredibly grim without his own layer of zany over it all or exclude a lot). Anyway, he said "Chris Pine" and presumably didn't break into maniacal cackling by sheer force of will.
3) Another time, he was asked how he thinks Chris Pine should handle the pay dispute preventing the fourth AOS film. His opinion was that Pine shouldn't bend an inch, because he's talented and attractive and so identified with his role that they can't really make those movies without him, but Pine can do plenty of things other than Star Trek. So if Paramount's going to make that much money, Pine should absolutely see his fair share and if not, walk, and good for him.
















