lol, tumblr
Dec. 3rd, 2012 02:04 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
anghraineNot even f-locking this.
Okay, another anti-woobification rant popped on my dash, of the 'I just don't understand stupid shallow fangirls acting like their woobies are just misunderstood, why do they have to ruin the characters for the rest of us' variety. So I responded with, well, that'd be because they think they ARE misunderstood, at least to some extent, and fandoms often focus on dark characters' softer sides because it's what conflicts with the general villainy and makes them interesting in the first place, and come on, other people interpreting characters differently doesn't ruin the characters, even if we think the other interpretations make no sense. We can disagree and point out problematic trends and all that without going all STOP HAVING FUN, GUYS at swaths of fandom.
(Or: If you think Darcy is a hot-tempered, impulsive, fiercely authoritarian, debonair, alpha male, sex god who constantly broods over the torment of his soul, I think you're wrong. I don't, however, think that you're stupid, immoral, or somehow wrecking Darcy as I see him in the book, I just disagree. And probably don't like your fic. That's okay.)
I was unprepared, however, for the OP's brilliantly persuasive rebuttal:
go away i don't care
Wow, I'm crushed. Of course, then other people were responding to me, and she complained about that, then deleted her posts, and now she's complaining that those people just don't understand, she was talking about woobies and not just liking villains, her username is a villain, some people just have no reading comprehension, GOD. Because, clearly, we weren't talking at all about woobification, just about enjoying evil characters being evil. Getting a kick out of Palpatine's machinations and MUAHAHAHAHAHA ULTIMATE POWAH!!! is the only proper way to like villains.
Okay, another anti-woobification rant popped on my dash, of the 'I just don't understand stupid shallow fangirls acting like their woobies are just misunderstood, why do they have to ruin the characters for the rest of us' variety. So I responded with, well, that'd be because they think they ARE misunderstood, at least to some extent, and fandoms often focus on dark characters' softer sides because it's what conflicts with the general villainy and makes them interesting in the first place, and come on, other people interpreting characters differently doesn't ruin the characters, even if we think the other interpretations make no sense. We can disagree and point out problematic trends and all that without going all STOP HAVING FUN, GUYS at swaths of fandom.
(Or: If you think Darcy is a hot-tempered, impulsive, fiercely authoritarian, debonair, alpha male, sex god who constantly broods over the torment of his soul, I think you're wrong. I don't, however, think that you're stupid, immoral, or somehow wrecking Darcy as I see him in the book, I just disagree. And probably don't like your fic. That's okay.)
I was unprepared, however, for the OP's brilliantly persuasive rebuttal:
go away i don't care
Wow, I'm crushed. Of course, then other people were responding to me, and she complained about that, then deleted her posts, and now she's complaining that those people just don't understand, she was talking about woobies and not just liking villains, her username is a villain, some people just have no reading comprehension, GOD. Because, clearly, we weren't talking at all about woobification, just about enjoying evil characters being evil. Getting a kick out of Palpatine's machinations and MUAHAHAHAHAHA ULTIMATE POWAH!!! is the only proper way to like villains.
Re: OKAY HERE HAVE COMMENT-FIC!
on 2012-12-09 08:22 pm (UTC)Re: OKAY HERE HAVE COMMENT-FIC!
on 2012-12-14 01:50 am (UTC)Re: OKAY HERE HAVE COMMENT-FIC!
on 2012-12-14 01:52 am (UTC)Re: OKAY HERE HAVE COMMENT-FIC!
on 2012-12-14 03:25 am (UTC)Re: OKAY HERE HAVE COMMENT-FIC!
on 2012-12-14 03:27 am (UTC)Re: OKAY HERE HAVE COMMENT-FIC!
on 2012-12-18 04:15 am (UTC)this icon is strangely relevant for Charlotte
on 2012-12-18 07:00 pm (UTC)Re: this icon is strangely relevant for Charlotte
on 2012-12-19 01:21 am (UTC)...um, my reaction to that was actually to want to make a cup of tea, possibly with spirits therein, for Darcy? Which is a very concrete way of saying, "Oh, dear."
Re: this icon is strangely relevant for Charlotte
on 2012-12-19 01:27 am (UTC)