anghraine: a close-up of a female half-elf glancing doubtfully to the side (shadowheart (side-eye))
I’m so tired of posts about how the OP never liked the thing made by [creator who turned out to be an awful person], they always knew it was mediocre, and now, aha, vindication.

This isn’t just about JKR, for the record; the specific instance that set it off was about someone else, though of course I’ve seen it with HP.

It redirects the conversation onto the quality of the creation, and the quality does not matter.

The person is awful regardless of whether they’re good at [thing]. The conversation around that doesn’t need to devolve into arguments about whether [thing] actually is good or not, which is at best a distraction. Going on about your good judgment isn’t helping people, it’s just patting yourself on the back and often sneering at those who didn’t have your ~vision, including less visionary people who are among the terrible person’s targets. That is, I hope obviously, a shitty thing to do!

And it also very frequently implies that people’s awfulness—bigotry, abusiveness, whatever—is going to be apparent in their art or their outwards conduct. Often this isn’t true and leads to such obviously bad faith scrutinizing of their work that it weakens the actual, real objections to them as a person. Terrible people are very, very often perfectly upstanding outwardly and, when artists, creators of high quality work. There is absolutely no need to make it about how right-thinking people will know there’s something off about the person in question, or just dislike them before the revelation. Plenty of right-thinking people won’t know and have no clear reason to dislike them!

Just. It’s not about you and how right you were and scolding the less prophetic. It’s about the terribleness of the person and the cultural strains they’re participating in and the harm done.
anghraine: a painting of a manor backed by high woody hills, with scattered trees in the foreground (pemberley)
[personal profile] heckofabecca responded to this post:

Prettttty sure I came for the Austen?

I replied:

Haha, I think so, actually! But most of my followers came with the sequel trilogy and that one HP post.

[personal profile] tree said:

CECILY <3

I replied:

MY GIRL!!
anghraine: jyn erso and cassian andor flirting in the hangar bay (jyn and cassian [hangar])

I was looking at my AO3 page, and … I have a pretty jumbled mix of feelings about what I’ve written, honestly.

I don’t expect many people to care, but going with the top 11:

1. Season of Courtship (Austen): I wrote it at 19 alongside The Rich Are Always Respectable, alternating on a schedule, in fits of depression and mania. A few years later (in a better frame of mind), I revised it—some sections quite substantially. I’m glad people like it but feel kind of weird about it being The One.

2. per ardua ad astra (Star Wars): I wrote this in a haze of Rogue One feelings between early 2017 and mid-2018. I was dealing with some mental health issues, but not 2005 hell, and it helped with them. I feel vaguely bad about the perpetually unfinished half of a chapter on my Drive, but I am fond of the fic generally.

3. But Thou Didst Not Leave His Soul In Hell (Star Wars): I was listening to The Messiah and had the idea of a bunch of short SW fics set to various lyrics; this is one of them. It was a strange but fun project and super soothing after Austen fandom, so it’s nice to see such a short thing up here.

4. we get dark, only to shine (The Borgias): I wrote this during my MA, and the academic and fic research crossed over heavily, which made both easier. I’d finally gotten diagnosed as bipolar and put on mood stabilizers, I was getting A’s in everything, and its fandom was the absolute nicest I’ve ever been in. Best fandom experience bar none.

5. tolerably well acquainted (Austen): I had some P&P feelings and started self-indulgent drawer fic that just kind of grew. Slowly. Very slowly. But eventually it reached the point where I decided to post what I had, and … it’s still ongoing.

6. Contradictions and Varieties (Austen): this comes from my better Austen fandom days. There was a prompt at Firthness and the first half of the fic was my fill for it, and then I tacked on an ending later. I feel like the division is very obvious and it’s pretty uneven, so I’m kind of meh about it.

7. Anomaly (Austen): the ace!Darcy fic, inspired by the ace manifestos community on Dreamwidth. I thought of actually writing a manifesto for him, and then just wrote fic instead. It’s not my best fic, but it is my precious child and every nice comment warms my heart to this day.

8. Ten Facts About Harry Potter (Harry Potter): my take on Slytherin!Harry, something I’ve always deeply loved in concept and very rarely in execution. It’s … eh.

9. First Impressions (Austen): also not my best fic, but I planned it for a year and then wrote it for a big bang, and it largely turned out the way I wanted it to turn out. That doesn’t often happen! And I had friends who were super encouraging the whole time, and was in a good place mentally, and … it was a joy, really. 

10. The Talk (Austen): It sure exists. (More seriously, it’s not really “me” and feels very remote.)

11. Redemption (Star Wars): this was my first SW fic ever and I shoved a lot of my ambivalence about ROTJ and the PT into it while trying to stay away from fix-fic implications. It was really fun to write for a new fandom, so I just did whatever popped into my head, and … it doesn’t bother me, since I had such a good time writing it, but in retrospect it’s a strange little thing.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[ETA 2/28/2024: I don't think my top 11 by kudos looks exactly the same now, though it's similar: 1) Season of Courtship, 2) But Thou Didst Not Leave His Soul in Hell, 3) per ardua ad astra, 4) we get dark, only to shine, 5) Contradictions and Varieties, 6) Anomaly, 7) tolerably well acquainted, 8) The Talk, 9) Ten Facts About Harry Potter, 10) A Cunning Plan, and 11) First Impressions.]
anghraine: an enraged korra propels herself in the avatar state (korra (avatar state))
I am generally opposed to deleting my Internet history, but I kind of want to nuke all my Tumblr HP posts from orbit.

(I haven't changed my mind about the specific opinions in them, but overall. Well.)
anghraine: vader and luke dueling in esb (anakin and luke)
An anon said:

I finally found someone who agree with me about: 1) what Luke did for Vader was out of intense love for his father, and not out of pure kindness exactly (as you say, “he’s more of a loving person than an forgiving one,” because before knowing who Vader was he hated Vader and wanted him dead) and 2) Luke and Anakin are Gryffindors, not Hufflepuffs (this one is so controversial, but I’m so glad at least one person agrees with me! One of Hufflepuff’s qualities on Pottermore is freaking PATIENCE??!)

I replied:

You have my sword, anon! We are few but stalwart :)
anghraine: tarrlok from legend of korra smirking (tarrlok (smug))
I did the top nine original Tumblr posts thing, and … I am both surprised and delighted that my Water Tribe post made the cut.

On the 29th, gritsinmisery replied:

How do you do that thing?

I said:

It’s here!

Mine are 1) a Yoda comic I thought was funny in 2012, 2) midnight grumping about Harry Potter, 3) a collection of outdated links to sf/f publishers, 4) my ??? at the idea that fandom is for kids, 5) a link to a girl dressed as Jyn Erso, 6) a “reblog if you were born in 1985 or earlier” from 2013, 7) a collection of Water Tribe characters looking gorgeous, 8) a bell hooks quote, and 9) grumping about Austen.
anghraine: a stock photo of a book with a leaf on it (book with leaf)
I reblogged the Sorting Hat Chats quiz here—their system isn't quite how I understand the canon houses, but it's lots of fun. 

According to the quiz, I'm living my best Slytherclaw life ;)
anghraine: a painting of a man c. 1800 with a book and a pen; the words love, pride, and delicacy in the upper corner (darcy (love)
More P&P + @sortinghatchats, following from Elizabeth’s Slytherin/Gryffindor sorting: Darcy!

Read more... )
anghraine: various thickly-bound books on the shelves of a library (library)
I’m bored and procrastinating, so … coming back to P&P and sortinghatchats with Elizabeth Bennet.

Read more... )
anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (Default)
An anon on Tumblr asked, in response to this post:

But was Harry gifted because he was gifted or did it seem he was gifted because he had a part of Voldemorts soul in him, transferring many of Voldys powers to him, which could include excelling at the Dark Arts

Read more... )
anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (the trio [ot3])
...somehow. I wrote it as a grumpy middle of the night rant, a bnf friend reblogged it, even more bnf-ish bnfs reblogged it from her, and by the point MuggleNet reblogged it I was just o_O.

Still stand by it, though.

Read more... )
anghraine: padmé, coloured sepia; text: indistinct calligraphy (padmé [sepia])
In relation to this post, thusspakesophie on Tumblr asked:

I loved your Hogwarts sorting + loyalty essay! But I'm having a hard time squaring Padme-as-Hufflepuff with what we see of her leadership style. Hufflepuffs operate in teams by establishing consensus (eg Ernie Macmillan's constant appeals to his audience, or Mark Watney's humour->group cohesion) but Padme is VERY independent. She'll ditch anyone who isn't performing and often steps in herself to solve things. She rarely consults others. I think her loyalty is ideological; she's a Gryffindor.

Read more... )
anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (anakin [grievances])
caripr94 on Tumblr asked:

Hey there! I'm a big Star Wars fan and I've seen how you sort the characters into Hogwarts houses, such as Anakin being in Gryffindor and Padmé being in Hufflepuff, but I also see other people do the opposite because of Anakin's loyalty and work ethic and Padmé's recklessness and idealism, and I'm like "I don't know". How would you respond to that?

Read more... )
anghraine: padmé, coloured sepia; text: indistinct calligraphy (padmé [sepia])
So a post I wrote about Padmé is making the rounds, cool.

At the beginning of it, I mentioned in passing to an anon that, why yes, I have opinions on Padmé! It's why I am unswervably convinced that she's a Hufflepuff! 

And the rest was pretty much about how her faithful, hard-working commitment to justice and the general welfare is ultimately self-destructive because she's allowed herself almost nothing else. 

Reblog: "I agree with everything except Padmé's a Slytherin"

me: ?

???

??????????????????????????


Hits meme!

May. 3rd, 2016 09:48 pm
anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (darcy and elizabeth)
I stole it from [personal profile] tree , because I want to feel accomplished despite having not written anything. (And also, I'm procrastinating on reading the second half of Mill on the Floss, which scarred me in my sensitive adolescence.)

Read more... )
anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (Default)
I've been thinking for awhile of putting all my serious meta together in some easily accessible place, since I get asked for particular links often enough, and I've posted enough that it's inconvenient to search my meta tag. It's very much a work in progress right now, but I tried to include the ones that people most often ask me about, use the most recent links, and add a brief description for each, as my titles tend to the unhelpful.

Read more... ) 
anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (vader [grievances])
When I wrote last year's au_bigbangs, I vaguely referred to two other fandoms within the stories - for the lulz! - and then amused myself by stuffing as many references to as many others of mine as I could shove in. I always meant to do a proper attribution post, but just ... forgot. But now I've remembered! So here they are. (The citations are in white, so feel free to guess if it amuses you.)

attribution time )


memes )
anghraine: luke skywalker in black; text: bamf (luke [bamf])
Yes, these go on forever, and I went off on tangents at pretty much every opportunity. This, of course, is one of them -- the whole thing is my response to maybe one paragraph, and at that, rather tangentially related to it. It's a little shorter, though, since I'm now trying to separate these into vaguely cohesive units, though.

Read more... )

Profile

anghraine: vader extending his lightsaber; text: and now for the airing of grievances! (Default)
Anghraine

April 2025

S M T W T F S
  1234 5
6789101112
1314 151617 18 19
20 21 2223242526
27282930   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Apr. 23rd, 2025 10:59 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios