Anghraine

sulfin-evend said:

I love your take on Gondor. What do you make of Boromir's quote in the council of Elrond paraphrasing "those who shelter behind us give us much praise but little help". I presume he is talking about other Gondorians. And the Stewards are often referred to as Lords of Minas Tirth or lord of the city.

What does this mean for how Gondor and its provinces view themselves and how its armies function. Are the Princes of Dol Amroth minting their own coin? Do the lords of Morthond present their daughters at the Stewards court? Are all the lords related to each other in a tangle of blood and marriage ties or do they keep to their home fiefs? It could be envisioned so many ways I am curious to read your perspective.

I replied:

Thanks!

I’ve always taken the opposite reading of Boromir’s line—that he’s talking about the peoples of Middle-earth sheltering behind Gondor generally, and this is why (if I’m remembering correctly) the others at the council go out of their way to point out that it’s not just Gondor that’s protecting the people of Middle-earth.

That said, Tolkien described the Princes of Dol Amroth as almost independent, but not quite; they’re “tributary princes” who contribute … something … to Gondor as a state. So while it might not look exactly like taxation as we’d understand it and could refer to things other than money, I do think it suggests some degree of cohesion, if even the Princes of Dol Amroth (definitely the most powerful and independent of the regional nobles) have to contribute to the whole.

We do see that the fiefs have a lot of authority when it comes to what troops they raise and where they send them. They only sent 1/10th of the forces at their command to help defend Minas Tirith because they were so worried about their own people, and seem to have been entirely free to make that call (and the people of Minas Tirith are disappointed but not enraged). So there’s still quite a bit of regional power in the military sense, at least. But Tolkien also said that a Dúnadan king or Ruling Steward was a fairly absolute ruler in other ways (esp dealing with interpretation of law), so it may be that the lords’ authority is particularly pronounced in military matters and more limited in others.

I do imagine that there would be a lot of intermarriage between the Dúnadan noble families, given that there are only so many of them. While Gondorians have less hang-ups about ~purity than in the Kinstrife days, I think it’s still something people are conscious of, as with Éowyn’s joke that Faramir’s people will wonder why he didn’t choose a woman “of the race of Númenor” to be his wife (she doesn’t seem to think her ¼ Númenórean ancestry will count for Gondorians).

IMO it’s entirely probable that the Stewards and Princes of Dol Amroth have intermarried multiple times, say—not with first cousins (I think that taboo became pretty non-negotiable post-Akallabêth), but more distant connections. Perhaps Imrahil is recognizable as part-Elvish to Legolas despite the generational distance from Mithrellas because Imrahil’s actually descended from her many times over. Etc.

[ETA 5/24/2024: sulfin-evend did respond to this, but given that they acknowledged being "contrary" in this interaction and that they defended Elrond's profoundly racist characterization of modern Gondor, I didn't feel inclined to reply again.]

An anon asked:

So as I sit here with way too much time to ponder about all kinds of things, I find myself wondering why Imrahil didn't just take Faramir straight to the Houses of Healing instead of to his father. Do you have a theory? Is it simply due to the fact that Faramir was the ruling Steward's son, and it was an authoritarian issue? He could have brought Faramir to the Houses of Healing and THEN told Denethor. It would have been far less dramatic though.

I replied:

On the meta-level, I think it is for the dramatic imagery, and the parallel to Denethor’s farewell; Faramir’s welcome back depended on the manner of his return, and then we’re given that return “after great deeds,” but now he’s dying without awareness of his welcome. Imrahil’s remark underscores all this (I think deliberately).

In-story … yeah, I’d be inclined to attribute it to Denethor’s position.

I reblogged this post I made in Nov 2013:

Little Estel growing up in a place where no one dies or ages or changes, ever, except him

Estel is Aragorn and it fills his heart with pride and then he falls madly in love with the most unattainable woman on the planet and it means his own grief or breaking up his family eternally

Young Aragorn returns to his people, who he doesn’t actually know, and has to become a Dúnadan of the North, the Dúnadan, when he’s only ever been a not-quite-Elf. His mother dies.

Aragorn wanders all over the globe. At one point he goes to Gondor, the country of which he has to gain kingship at some undetermined point in the future. The Steward’s heir is one year older than he is, looks as much like an ancient Númenórean as he does—looks like his brother, if he had one—and has ancient Númenórean powers to go with his height and face, just like Aragorn. Denethor hates him and Aragorn has to walk carefully around him. He leaves when Denethor’s son, Boromir, is three.

Boromir shows up out of nowhere while Frodo is recovering in Rivendell. Little Boromir is now forty, a massive and supremely skilled warrior. He’s instantly suspicious of Aragorn. But they forge a relationship of mutual respect and perhaps even friendship through their assorted tribulations, yay!

Boromir, who Aragorn remembers as a toddler, dies in his arms.

( Read more... )

This has multiple dates because I did a writing meme, and I figured I'd compile the responses into one post.

( Read more... )

A further grab bag of my short(er) Tolkien posts on Tumblr:

On May 22nd, I said:

( Read more... )

...if it were, this is what the opening structure would be:

Letter 1: An Elrond hîr Imladris, adar muin, o Aragorn Edhelharn Aran Gondor ar Arnor

Letter 2: An Falavir Denethorion, nethion în, o Imrahíl Ernil Dol Amroth

Letter 3: [from Éomer, King of the Mark, to his dear sister Éowyn]

Letter 4: An Imrahíl Ernil Dol Amroth o Falavir, gwanur îr ar [arandur] Gondor

Letter 5: An Aragorn Arathornion Edhelharn, Aran Gondor ar Arnor ar Hîr i Mbair Annui, suilad o Falavir Denethorion, [arandur] Gondor

Letter 6: An Falavir Denethorion, Hîr i Minas ar [arandur] Gondor, o Aragorn Arathornion aran Arnor etc

Letter 7: [from Éowyn of the Riddermark to her brother, Éomer-King the beloved]

( i.e. )

...in quotes!

( Read more... )